Gandhi and V V S Aiyar shared a tumultuous rapport that epitomized the ideological rifts within the Indian independence movement. Aiyar, a staunch advocate of anarchism, often clashed with Gandhi’s principles of non-violence and structured political engagement. Despite Gandhi referring to him as a “fierce anarchist,” their interactions reflected a complex interplay of respect and disagreement. Aiyar’s fervent belief in the dismantling of state structures contrasted sharply with Gandhi’s vision of a decentralized, yet organized society rooted in moral and ethical governance. This divergence was not merely philosophical; it underscored the broader debates on means versus ends in the quest for independence.

Moreover, Aiyar’s alignment with the anarchist movement introduced radical elements to the discourse around Indian nationalism. His tactics included advocating for direct action, which often brought him at odds with more moderate leaders. Key points in their relationship include:

  • Disagreements on Tactics: Aiyar’s inclination towards violence conflicted with Gandhi’s commitment to ahimsa (non-violence).
  • Mutual Respect: Despite their differences, Gandhi recognized Aiyar’s passion and dedication to the cause.
  • Legacy of Thought: Aiyar influenced a section of youth in India to consider alternative methods for enacting social change.